About Coffey Modica LLP
Coffey Modica LLP is a defense litigation firm headquartered in Tarrytown, New York, founded in 2021. It was known as Coffey Modica O'Meara LLP until it adopted its current name in 2023. The firm represents businesses and insurance companies in liability claims, excess property and casualty matters, medical malpractice, nursing matters and other professional-industry disputes. Its listed practice areas include construction defect, cyber, technology and media, directors and officers, employment law, professional liability, and trucking and transportation, and it also describes appellate work as part of its litigation focus.
The firm lists New York offices in Tarrytown (100 White Plains Road) and Islandia on Long Island (1377 Motor Parkway, Suite 212). Its materials also refer to a Manhattan office at 14 Wall Street and a Buffalo office on Delaware Avenue, which it announced in 2026. Outside New York, the firm reports offices in Connecticut, New Jersey, Georgia and Florida.
| Type | Law firm |
|---|---|
| New York offices | Tarrytown, Islandia, New York (Manhattan, 14 Wall Street), Buffalo |
| Phone | 212-827-4501 |
| Website | coffeymodica.com |
| Registered NY attorneys | 42 |
Practice areas
Areas of work that Coffey Modica LLP describes on its own website. They describe the organization as a whole, not the practice of any individual attorney listed below.
Organization profile based on its official website and public sources (reviewed October 29, 2026). Attorney list from the New York State Unified Court System registration data. Not affiliated with Coffey Modica LLP.
Registered attorneys
David Aronowitz Currently registered Thomas Sica Currently registered Michael Mezzacappa Currently registered Adam Greenberg Currently registered Evan Echenthal Currently registered Robert Modica Currently registered Sandra Courbois Currently registered Colleen Hastie Currently registered Amy Benedict Currently registered Patricia Mooney Currently registeredRegistration status can change at any time. Confirm any attorney's current status through the official New York Attorney Search.